Reviews

“I absolutely loved this place! Our host, Julie, is incredible.

The place has great amenities and is comfortable, well-stocked, and conveniently located to many of the Lakes' wineries and breweries. The breakfast she served was delicious! We will be back!”

Lisa

May 25, 2026

“Serene and utterly charming. Julie is a fabulous hostess and a great cook!”

Charles

May 16, 2026

“The Oak and Anchor Inn was a delightful experience. The breakfast was amazing and our host, Julie was lovely.”

Claudia

May 12, 2026

“Julie was the best host ever! She was so nice and accommodating! I can't wait to go back to the immaculate inn!”

Kathleen 

April 20, 2026

“Our room was comfortable, quiet and spotless. The breakfasts delicious, plentiful and expertly prepared by Julie. Both Julie and Danny are super nice and great hosts. This is a beautiful place, both the home and grounds. It was nice that coffee, beverages and snacks were available in the dining room at all times.”

Victoria

March 31, 2026

“Exceptional!”

Steve 

February 18, 2026

“Daniel and Julie met me at the door with fresh towels when I came in during a downpour. They were so genuine and welcoming. Our room was spotless. The bed was so comfortable, I wanted to stay in bed all day! The breakfast was all Julie and she must have trained as a chef. YUMMY! Her daughter is lovely as well. Such a beautiful inn, in such a beautiful setting, with beautiful people running it. Can't recommend enough!”

Ruth

April 18, 2026

“Some places are simply a place to sleep. Oak & Anchor Inn is an experience! From the moment we arrived, Julie's kindness and genuine passion for creating an unforgettable stay were evident in everything she does. We were so happy we chose to stay just slightly off the lake. The drive along Coates Road, with its sweeping panoramic views of Keuka Lake, is absolutely breathtaking. It offers the perfect balance of peaceful countryside and easy access to the lake, all the wineries, restaurants, and attractions. The inn itself is beautifully preserved, full of historic charm, and impeccably maintained. Our room was spotless, comfortable, and equipped with everything we could possibly need. One of my favorite touches was discovering fragrant dried lavender tucked into the freshly hung towels—a small gesture that perfectly captures the level of thoughtfulness Julie puts into every guest's experience. Then there's breakfast! Every morning, we were treated to an exquisite three-course gourmet breakfast that would rival many fine restaurants. Beautifully presented on elegant china, each course was as stunning as it was delicious. Each afternoon, freshly baked treats—including cranberry-orange scones and the most incredible banana bread—were beautifully presented for guests to enjoy. As an added bonus, the inn is within walking distance of a fantastic brewery, where we enjoyed craft beer, delicious wood-fired pizza, and spectacular views. Oak & Anchor Inn exceeded EVERY expectation we had! Julie has created something truly special—a place that feels warm, welcoming, and unforgettable. We booked a Fall weekend before we even checked out—and we're already looking forward to breakfast!”

Michelle Nugent

July 6, 2026

“I had a great stay at the Oak and Anchor. It is a lovely property and is very well cared for. VERY quiet, and AC in the room was appreciated. I visit the area often, and there is a lot to do, from wine tasting to hiking to just taking beautiful drives. Breakfast was excellent and Julie had great information on local attractions, wineries and restaurants.”

Janet

Jul 13, 2026

“My partner and I had a lovely stay at Oak & Anchor. It was convenient to all of the Finger Lakes activities that interested us, including kayaking on Keuka Lake, walking the Keuka Outlet Trail, and wineries!

The breakfasts were fantastic - Julie is an amazing cook. Delicious and creatively plated, I enjoyed every single one of them!

Julie also maintains a well stocked fridge of beverages for guests to enjoy throughout the day. There were many snacks to choose from in the snack bin. Each afternoon, Julie put out pastries to be enjoyed with the tea or coffee available at the guest coffee station.

I highly recommend Oak & Anchor. We will be back!!”

Susan B.

July 14, 2026

“Wonderful stay with plentiful breakfast, amazing views and close to so many attractions, wineries, and restaurants.”

Clara

Jul 15, 2026

“The property was absolutely gorgeous. Julie was an amazing host. She was very helpful with local travel advice. The place was so quiet and restful. Breakfast is a must.”

Paul

Jul 20, 2026

“Breakfast both days of our stay were out of this world!

Julie, owner/host is a brilliant and imaginative chef.

Beautifully presented, really generous portions, delicious!

Best B&B breakfasts I've ever had.”

Robert

Jul 26, 2026

“We loved the property and its location. The home baked goods were my favorite. When I felt under the weather Julie was very helpful in getting me back on my feet quickly, I thank her a bunch. Can't wait to go back!”

richard

Jul 28, 2026